Lucy: “I’ll hold the ball, Charlie Brown, and you come running up and kick it”…Charlie: “Every year she pulls the same trick on me!”
–from the Peanuts football comic strip (Charles Schulz)
Recent events in Washington, D.C. and Hong Kong compelled me to change today’s post to discuss both.
To see what’s wrong with Washington, D.C., look no further than Congress and its handling of the most recent stimulus bill.
I’m reminded of my high school years when I would be up past midnight sitting at the kitchen table typing a term paper due later that morning. I’d had a few months to write it, but I’d put it off to the penultimate hour and put forth a less than stellar effort, even adding “junk” when necessary. But, c’mon man (or is it “person” now?)…I was only 16 years old!
Congress hemmed and hawed over a stimulus package months ago when everyone acknowledged people were hurting and needed financial assistance. Apropos for the season, it became a political football, and they kicked around various versions of a bill that represented a staggering sum of money. Of course, nothing was settled and, after the election, Speaker Pelosi brazenly announced the stimulus bill could move forward now that we’ll have a new president.
More debate ensued until Congress was up against the holiday recess, at which time the bill became a “Christmas tree,” on which members got to add their own ornaments, disguised as pork and special interest provisions. Americans would get $600 per person, in a way not properly targeted to those most in need, but millions would go to such initiatives as fisheries, gender studies in Pakistan, and two new Smithsonian museums, to name just a few misdirected provisions. We can debate the worthiness of these causes, but it’s hard to understand their relevance to the simple matter that the American economy and the personal economic situation of her citizens are hurting due to a pandemic mismanaged on many levels. Nonetheless, the bill was held hostage by Congress.
The simple fact is that these 535 individuals in Congress are in charge of the lives of over 300 million citizens. I’m all for our system of representative government, but we must hold those who lead us accountable. We complain about Congress but continue to send the same people back to Washington one election after another. With November’s election, there was some change in that regard, and I’m hopeful this will continue.
The reprehensible events of January 6 were a startling embarrassment for our country. An assault on Congress is not how we effect change in our country.
How did we get to that point? There’s plenty of blame to go around. The bonfire-building started 4 years ago. Biased media, journalists harboring agendas, pundits, politicians from both sides spouting vitriol, special interest groups, and the shameful performances of two presidential candidates in something loosely termed a debate all added timber to the pile. While I do not believe he thought people would invade the Capitol, President Trump did light the match when he ginned up his most partisan supporters and encouraged them to peacefully march on the Capitol.
It’s important to remember this: 74 million people voted to re-elect President Trump; only a few thousand criminals breached the Capitol. I can’t imagine what they were thinking, but I suspect they must have believed they had presidential cover for their actions. Some lost their lives and many will lose their freedom for their heinous acts.
President-elect Biden was quick to come to the podium and condemn the thugs who attacked the sacred “people’s house,” and he was right to do so. But his condemnation was conspicuously absent last summer as cities in Minnesota, Wisconsin, Washington, and Oregon sustained similar attacks. I suspect individuals in those cities thought their businesses and homes that were destroyed were every bit as sacred as our nation’s Capitol.
Also, did you notice the duplicitous behavior exhibited by members of Congress who support the defunding of police, but were some of the loudest voices regarding the lack of adequate law enforcement at the Capitol when it was attacked? Progressive ideas don’t always sound so rational when one’s own safety is at stake.
January 6 was a seminal moment for our nation. Hopefully, those who represent us in government will learn that their performance and behavior in part led to the events of the day, and they must desist from crying out that if the other side gets its way, Armageddon will ensue. If both sides treat their work as a zero-sum game, that’s exactly what we’ll get from them: nothing. Their behavior must change. If it doesn’t, in two years we have the opportunity to replace many of them–through an orderly and fair election process, not by an insurrection.
Jimmy Lai is a Hong Kong businessman and the founder of Apple Daily, a newspaper that supports democracy in Hong Kong. For his efforts, he’s been arrested, charged, detained, released on bail, and now detained again until his trial in April. On the now infamous 6th of January, 53 other voices for democracy in Hong Kong, one of whom is an American citizen, were also detained.
We cannot imagine such a thing happening in our country, where the loudest and most hateful voices are allowed to be heard. For that, we can celebrate. There’s still hope. As I’ve said before, most of us are moderates–center-left or center-right–and while we may not endorse their opinions, we tolerate the voices to the far-left and far-right as long as their expressions are made peacefully.
We are a great nation. Despite our divisions, I firmly believe the forces of hope and optimism, and the good they do, will far outweigh those of hatred and evil.
15 Comments
Leave A Comment
Lucy: “I’ll hold the ball, Charlie Brown, and you come running up and kick it”…Charlie: “Every year she pulls the same trick on me!”
–from the Peanuts football comic strip (Charles Schulz)
Recent events in Washington, D.C. and Hong Kong compelled me to change today’s post to discuss both.
To see what’s wrong with Washington, D.C., look no further than Congress and its handling of the most recent stimulus bill.
I’m reminded of my high school years when I would be up past midnight sitting at the kitchen table typing a term paper due later that morning. I’d had a few months to write it, but I’d put it off to the penultimate hour and put forth a less than stellar effort, even adding “junk” when necessary. But, c’mon man (or is it “person” now?)…I was only 16 years old!
Congress hemmed and hawed over a stimulus package months ago when everyone acknowledged people were hurting and needed financial assistance. Apropos for the season, it became a political football, and they kicked around various versions of a bill that represented a staggering sum of money. Of course, nothing was settled and, after the election, Speaker Pelosi brazenly announced the stimulus bill could move forward now that we’ll have a new president.
More debate ensued until Congress was up against the holiday recess, at which time the bill became a “Christmas tree,” on which members got to add their own ornaments, disguised as pork and special interest provisions. Americans would get $600 per person, in a way not properly targeted to those most in need, but millions would go to such initiatives as fisheries, gender studies in Pakistan, and two new Smithsonian museums, to name just a few misdirected provisions. We can debate the worthiness of these causes, but it’s hard to understand their relevance to the simple matter that the American economy and the personal economic situation of her citizens are hurting due to a pandemic mismanaged on many levels. Nonetheless, the bill was held hostage by Congress.
The simple fact is that these 535 individuals in Congress are in charge of the lives of over 300 million citizens. I’m all for our system of representative government, but we must hold those who lead us accountable. We complain about Congress but continue to send the same people back to Washington one election after another. With November’s election, there was some change in that regard, and I’m hopeful this will continue.
The reprehensible events of January 6 were a startling embarrassment for our country. An assault on Congress is not how we effect change in our country.
How did we get to that point? There’s plenty of blame to go around. The bonfire-building started 4 years ago. Biased media, journalists harboring agendas, pundits, politicians from both sides spouting vitriol, special interest groups, and the shameful performances of two presidential candidates in something loosely termed a debate all added timber to the pile. While I do not believe he thought people would invade the Capitol, President Trump did light the match when he ginned up his most partisan supporters and encouraged them to peacefully march on the Capitol.
It’s important to remember this: 74 million people voted to re-elect President Trump; only a few thousand criminals breached the Capitol. I can’t imagine what they were thinking, but I suspect they must have believed they had presidential cover for their actions. Some lost their lives and many will lose their freedom for their heinous acts.
President-elect Biden was quick to come to the podium and condemn the thugs who attacked the sacred “people’s house,” and he was right to do so. But his condemnation was conspicuously absent last summer as cities in Minnesota, Wisconsin, Washington, and Oregon sustained similar attacks. I suspect individuals in those cities thought their businesses and homes that were destroyed were every bit as sacred as our nation’s Capitol.
Also, did you notice the duplicitous behavior exhibited by members of Congress who support the defunding of police, but were some of the loudest voices regarding the lack of adequate law enforcement at the Capitol when it was attacked? Progressive ideas don’t always sound so rational when one’s own safety is at stake.
January 6 was a seminal moment for our nation. Hopefully, those who represent us in government will learn that their performance and behavior in part led to the events of the day, and they must desist from crying out that if the other side gets its way, Armageddon will ensue. If both sides treat their work as a zero-sum game, that’s exactly what we’ll get from them: nothing. Their behavior must change. If it doesn’t, in two years we have the opportunity to replace many of them–through an orderly and fair election process, not by an insurrection.
Jimmy Lai is a Hong Kong businessman and the founder of Apple Daily, a newspaper that supports democracy in Hong Kong. For his efforts, he’s been arrested, charged, detained, released on bail, and now detained again until his trial in April. On the now infamous 6th of January, 53 other voices for democracy in Hong Kong, one of whom is an American citizen, were also detained.
We cannot imagine such a thing happening in our country, where the loudest and most hateful voices are allowed to be heard. For that, we can celebrate. There’s still hope. As I’ve said before, most of us are moderates–center-left or center-right–and while we may not endorse their opinions, we tolerate the voices to the far-left and far-right as long as their expressions are made peacefully.
We are a great nation. Despite our divisions, I firmly believe the forces of hope and optimism, and the good they do, will far outweigh those of hatred and evil.
15 Comments
-
Well said, my friend! And we know Antifa was at the front of the explosion of destruction on January 6th with sticks and bulky clubs, inciting people to use force, and committing murder. They posed as peaceful Trump supporters at first to get to the front of the protests, then wreaked havoc. It is extremely upsetting to see our country being hijacked by this group that should be arrested and shut down. I pray for our country and cry for the mess we’re in, trying to have faith that we will wake up and clean up our act. Please forgive my rant – but our country needs to act more mature about all of this!!😞
-
Hi Lissa,
The FBI has said there is no indication that antifa infiltrated the crowd last week. CNN has also debunked this.
The Rep from Florida cited a story in The Washington Times purporting that facial recognition software from the company XRVision had identified antifa. That story has been pulled from the Times website. XRVision has told The Daily Beast and Buzzfeed that the antifa story is an outright falsehood. However, they did identify two Neo-Nazis and one QAnon supporter in the crowd.
I also pray for our country. I hope we can take a collective deep breath and try to listen to each other so that we can begin to understand each other. Thanks.
-
-
Reading this is like adding book ends to steady a rack of random books placed haphazardly on my shelf! I needed this!
Great read.:))) -
Thanks for sharing your heart, my friend. I strive to teach my daughter the same love for and respect of others that I was taught by my parents (and many in my church and Scouting communities). This is so difficult to do today, given the hate that is coming from many directions. I, too, pray that we will heal.
-
Tim, Really enjoyed reading this and agree with everything that you said and look forward to your next post. It must be our common love of God, baseball, fly fishing and even getting a 5th dog that gives us a shared view of the world.
-
I posted this over the weekend. Many of our citizens see themselves as Patriots battling a corrupt government. Right or wrong, it is their perception and one’s perception is one’s reality.
“The American Revolution was started by a small group of radicals who felt government was out of control. Remember that when you ponder the events of this week. There is a group of elitists running the USA. They didn’t start out as elitists, but holding office corrupted them. Old cliche about power corrupting and absolute power corrupting absolutely still holds true. Look at the wealth held by our representatives and ask how they achieved such wealth. The Clintons claimed to be flat broke when they left the White House. Check out the Obama home on the coast of Massachusetts. We live in a great country. Want to keep it great? Pay attention to what your representatives do – not what they say. Another cliche says “how do you know they are lying – because their lips were moving”. Government is not the answer nor is it the villian. We, the people, who choose to sit back and watch rather than take the initiative to research, speak up, take action, be the change we seek are the guilty ones and will surely reap the woes of our inaction. My prayer is the USA will survive as a great country for the benefit of my children and grandchildren. My fear is the USA will implode through greed, self-centeredness, the belief that someone else will take care of it, a you-owe-me attitude, me first mentality or a host of ego centeredness. I am my brother’s keeper, but my brother is responsible for doing his part. Equality should provide a step up. It should not bring others down so they may wallow in whatever form inequality may take. Take heed my fellow countrymen, take action – be the change you wish to see!”-
Hi Bruce,
I believe we need to pay attention to both what our elected representatives say and do. When the President repeatedly says the election was stolen, and makes statements in front of a crowd saying that weakness won’t “take our country back” – I hope you’d agree that in light of last week, words do indeed matter.
I agree with you that we have to do our homework and use critical thinking. It takes time, but sometimes we need to move away from our echo chambers and determine if we’ve swallowed a story just because it “seems” right.
I hope we can all figure out how to compromise and get things done. It is a sad state where either party figures the only way to enact change is to have super-majorities in both legislative branches.
-
-
I keep thinking about a line from one of our favorite movies: “He is interested in two things, and two things only: making you afraid of it, and telling you who’s to blame for it. That, ladies and gentlemen, is how you win elections.” And sadly, that’s what both sides do now — tap into our emotions and make us afraid of what the other side will mean for our futures. Of course, there is much to be feared from extremism, but as you said, most of us live in the center.
-
I hope you are right!
-
Thank you Tim for another thought provoking, emotional, and uplifting piece. As usual you hit the nail on the head on both counts! Keep them coming….we need them!
-
Tim,
It’s been repeated so often that perhaps it’s accepted as truth. But, the statement that Joe Biden’s condemnation of violence was conspicuously absent during the summer of 2020 is just not true. If you do a search, you’ll see that he spoke out on CNN May 29 – remember George Floyd was killed on May 25. There are other statements & quotes from Biden condemning violence dated 5/31, 6/2, 7/28/ 8/26 and 8/31. August 31 statement after violence in Portland: “I condemn violence of every kind by any one, whether on the left or the right”. He also challenged the President to clearly say he opposed all violence. -
Thank you Tim, for your sound judgement and critical thinking!! We need more people like you that aren’t afraid to THINK.
Well said, my friend! And we know Antifa was at the front of the explosion of destruction on January 6th with sticks and bulky clubs, inciting people to use force, and committing murder. They posed as peaceful Trump supporters at first to get to the front of the protests, then wreaked havoc. It is extremely upsetting to see our country being hijacked by this group that should be arrested and shut down. I pray for our country and cry for the mess we’re in, trying to have faith that we will wake up and clean up our act. Please forgive my rant – but our country needs to act more mature about all of this!!😞
Hi Lissa,
The FBI has said there is no indication that antifa infiltrated the crowd last week. CNN has also debunked this.
The Rep from Florida cited a story in The Washington Times purporting that facial recognition software from the company XRVision had identified antifa. That story has been pulled from the Times website. XRVision has told The Daily Beast and Buzzfeed that the antifa story is an outright falsehood. However, they did identify two Neo-Nazis and one QAnon supporter in the crowd.
I also pray for our country. I hope we can take a collective deep breath and try to listen to each other so that we can begin to understand each other. Thanks.
Reading this is like adding book ends to steady a rack of random books placed haphazardly on my shelf! I needed this!
Great read.:)))
Thanks for sharing your heart, my friend. I strive to teach my daughter the same love for and respect of others that I was taught by my parents (and many in my church and Scouting communities). This is so difficult to do today, given the hate that is coming from many directions. I, too, pray that we will heal.
Tim, Really enjoyed reading this and agree with everything that you said and look forward to your next post. It must be our common love of God, baseball, fly fishing and even getting a 5th dog that gives us a shared view of the world.
I posted this over the weekend. Many of our citizens see themselves as Patriots battling a corrupt government. Right or wrong, it is their perception and one’s perception is one’s reality.
“The American Revolution was started by a small group of radicals who felt government was out of control. Remember that when you ponder the events of this week. There is a group of elitists running the USA. They didn’t start out as elitists, but holding office corrupted them. Old cliche about power corrupting and absolute power corrupting absolutely still holds true. Look at the wealth held by our representatives and ask how they achieved such wealth. The Clintons claimed to be flat broke when they left the White House. Check out the Obama home on the coast of Massachusetts. We live in a great country. Want to keep it great? Pay attention to what your representatives do – not what they say. Another cliche says “how do you know they are lying – because their lips were moving”. Government is not the answer nor is it the villian. We, the people, who choose to sit back and watch rather than take the initiative to research, speak up, take action, be the change we seek are the guilty ones and will surely reap the woes of our inaction. My prayer is the USA will survive as a great country for the benefit of my children and grandchildren. My fear is the USA will implode through greed, self-centeredness, the belief that someone else will take care of it, a you-owe-me attitude, me first mentality or a host of ego centeredness. I am my brother’s keeper, but my brother is responsible for doing his part. Equality should provide a step up. It should not bring others down so they may wallow in whatever form inequality may take. Take heed my fellow countrymen, take action – be the change you wish to see!”
Hi Bruce,
I believe we need to pay attention to both what our elected representatives say and do. When the President repeatedly says the election was stolen, and makes statements in front of a crowd saying that weakness won’t “take our country back” – I hope you’d agree that in light of last week, words do indeed matter.
I agree with you that we have to do our homework and use critical thinking. It takes time, but sometimes we need to move away from our echo chambers and determine if we’ve swallowed a story just because it “seems” right.
I hope we can all figure out how to compromise and get things done. It is a sad state where either party figures the only way to enact change is to have super-majorities in both legislative branches.
I keep thinking about a line from one of our favorite movies: “He is interested in two things, and two things only: making you afraid of it, and telling you who’s to blame for it. That, ladies and gentlemen, is how you win elections.” And sadly, that’s what both sides do now — tap into our emotions and make us afraid of what the other side will mean for our futures. Of course, there is much to be feared from extremism, but as you said, most of us live in the center.
A prescient quote from “The American President!”
I hope you are right!
Thank you Tim for another thought provoking, emotional, and uplifting piece. As usual you hit the nail on the head on both counts! Keep them coming….we need them!
Tim,
It’s been repeated so often that perhaps it’s accepted as truth. But, the statement that Joe Biden’s condemnation of violence was conspicuously absent during the summer of 2020 is just not true. If you do a search, you’ll see that he spoke out on CNN May 29 – remember George Floyd was killed on May 25. There are other statements & quotes from Biden condemning violence dated 5/31, 6/2, 7/28/ 8/26 and 8/31. August 31 statement after violence in Portland: “I condemn violence of every kind by any one, whether on the left or the right”. He also challenged the President to clearly say he opposed all violence.
If you’re correct (and it sounds like you were keeping score!), I stand corrected and should have used the left, rather than specifically Biden, as a more generalized opinion that they were either okay with or silent on the havoc of the 2020 summer. Generally, there’s no denying that.
Thank you Tim, as always you present sound judgement and aren’t afraid to demonstrate critical thinking!
Thank you Tim, for your sound judgement and critical thinking!! We need more people like you that aren’t afraid to THINK.